Humanities : Commonwealth of Virginia v. Allen, Critical Evaluation of Court Case help

Critical Evaluation of Court Case

It is important to understand the impact an expert testimony may have in the ultimate decision made by a court. In addition, it is helpful for practitioners of forensic psychology to be able to read and understand legal cases.

Tasks:

Click  here to review the case  Commonwealth of Virginia v. Allen (2005).

The case describes an appellate legal opinion or court decision involving expert witness testimony. When a case is appealed, it goes to an appellate or to a higher court. The appellate court then reviews the findings of the lower court, which in this case was the trial court. The appellate court offered the following two opinions:

  • The first opinion ( Commonwealth of Virginia v. Allen, 2005, pp. 1–24) is the majority opinion and is the one that counts.
  • The second opinion ( Commonwealth of Virginia v. Allen, 2005, pp. 24–31) is an opinion filed by a minority of judges who concurred (agreed) in part and dissented (disagreed) in part with the majority of the judges who ruled.

After reading the appellate legal opinion, write a 2- to 3-page paper addressing the following:

  • Discuss whether either of the expert witnesses in this case acted unethically. Support your opinion with the relevant APA or specialty ethical guidelines.
  • Indicate whether you agree with the majority decision or the minority concurring or dissenting opinion. Explain why.

The paper should be in APA style.

Reference:

Commonwealth of Virginia v. Allen, 609 S.E.2d 4 (Va. 2005).


Answers

Related Questions

Business Law : Health Models...

HEALTH MODELSMEDICAL ANDPSYCHOLOGICAL/SOCIOLOGICAL/BEHAVIORAL MODELSNAMEINSTITUTIONALAFFILIATIONMEDICAL MODELMedical model of treatmentfocuses on psyc...

History : Essay On Bible Figures...

Running head: CHARACTERS FROM THE OLD TESTAMENTCharacters from the Old TestamentLearners nameAffiliated Institute2The first book under discussion is t...

History : Voyages...

Running head: TRANS-ATLANTIC SLAVE TRADETrans-Atlantic Slave TradeNameInstructorCourseInstitution AffiliationDateTRANS-ATLANTIC SLAVE TRADE2Trans-Atla...

Computer Science : Methods For Evaluating Project...

Running Head: Methods of Evaluating Project PerformanceName:Admission Number:Course:Date of Submission:Lectures Name:1Running Head: Methods of Evaluat...

Philosophy : Logics Questions Answered...

Question# 1Use this key to symbolize the following sentences:A = Art attends class.G = Art graduates.H = Art completes his homework.L = Art does well...

Health & Medical : Health Services Hrm...

Running head: HEALTH SERVICES HRM1Health Services HRMNameInstitutionDateHUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT2Health Services Human Resource ManagementQ1The Joint...

Computer Science : Mobile Devices In The Workplace...

Running Head: MOBILE DEVICES IN THE WORKPLACEMobile Devices in the WorkplaceNameInstructorInstitutional AffiliationDate1MOBILE DEVICES IN THE WORKPLAC...

Writing : The Best Cleanser...

Running Head: The Best Cleanser.1The Best Cleanser:Students Name:Course Title:University Affiliation:Date:The Best Cleanser.2Extreme objective of the...

Marketing : Questions...

1. Media planning processMedia planning is the selection of platform of the media in order to be used by the clients.This is to means selecting the me...

Psychology : Final Paper Us Interview...

Final PaperStudent NameCollege/University1. Describe the context of the interview, the circumstances, if other people were present,the persons body la...

Business : Identifying And Managing Risk...

Running head: IDENTIFYING AND MANAGING RISKIdentifying and Managing RiskNameTutorInstitutionCourseDate1IDENTIFYING AND MANAGING RISK2IntroductionRisk...

Marketing : Need Two Pages Added On Highlighted Ta...

Running head: SMS AND E-BLAST MARKETINGSMS and E-Blast MarketingNameInstitution1SMS AND E-BLAST MARKETING2SMS and E-Blast MarketingSMS MarketingOver t...

English : Educational Sucess...

Surname 1NameCourseTutorDateEducational SuccessSuccess means achievement of an action in a specified period of time or within aspecified parameter. Su...

Art & Design : Comparing Works Of Art Edited...

INSERT SURNAME: 1NameCourseTutorDateCOMPARING WORKS OF ARTAlexis Rockman is an artist born in 1962 in New York. The artist loves the nature and hepain...

Other : Direct Level Leadership....

Surname.1Name:Professor:Course:Date:Direct Leadership StyleDirect leadership refers to the type of leadership whereby the leader engages his or hersub...

Writing : African Kinship...

Running Head: KINSHIP1KinshipNameInstitutional AffiliationKINSHIP2Kinship involves blood relationship which includes family ties, consanguinity andcom...

Business Law : Police...

Running head: POLICE BRUTALITY AND RACISMPolice Brutality and RacismName:Course:Instructor:Delivery Date:1POLICE BRUTALITY AND RACISM2Police brutality...

English : Evaluations Edited...

Running Head: PROJECT EVALUATION1ITEC 201 Semester Project: Phase 3Project EvaluationName:Group Name:Instructions:For each of the evaluations of the o...

English : Artificial Intelligence...

Insert Surname 1Artificial IntelligenceInstitutional affiliationDate29th November 2018Artificial Intelligence (AI) has staggering power in the process...

Psychology : Cognitive Development Revision...

Running head: COGNITIVE DEVELOPMENTCognitive DevelopmentNameTutorInstitutionCourseDateCOGNITIVE DEVELOPMENTCognitive development refers to a comprehen...

Economics : Efficiency And Cost Of Production...

Running head: EFFICIENCY AND COST OF PRODUCTIONEfficiency and Cost of ProductionNameInstitution1EFFICIENCY AND COST OF PRODUCTIONEfficiency and Cost o...

Business : Production And Operations Management....

Production and operation managementName of the studentAffiliation nameI..Production management involves applying the principles of management inproduc...

Management : Clothes R Us...

Running Head: ANALYSIS AND PROJECT MANAGEMENT INSTITUTEAnalysis and Project Management InstituteStudents NameProfessors NameCourse TitleDate1ANALYSIS...

Environmental Science : Sociology Of Migration...

Running head: LITERATURE REVIEW1Literature Review on the Sociology of MigrationNameInstitutional AffiliationLITERATURE REVIEW2Literature Review on the...

If you didn't find the right answer

Ask Your Questions, We'll notify you once someone answers it