Critical Evaluation of Court Case

It is important to understand the impact an expert testimony may have in the ultimate decision made by a court. In addition, it is helpful for practitioners of forensic psychology to be able to read and understand legal cases.

Tasks:

Click  here to review the case  Commonwealth of Virginia v. Allen (2005).

The case describes an appellate legal opinion or court decision involving expert witness testimony. When a case is appealed, it goes to an appellate or to a higher court. The appellate court then reviews the findings of the lower court, which in this case was the trial court. The appellate court offered the following two opinions:

  • The first opinion ( Commonwealth of Virginia v. Allen, 2005, pp. 1–24) is the majority opinion and is the one that counts.
  • The second opinion ( Commonwealth of Virginia v. Allen, 2005, pp. 24–31) is an opinion filed by a minority of judges who concurred (agreed) in part and dissented (disagreed) in part with the majority of the judges who ruled.

After reading the appellate legal opinion, write a 2- to 3-page paper addressing the following:

  • Discuss whether either of the expert witnesses in this case acted unethically. Support your opinion with the relevant APA or specialty ethical guidelines.
  • Indicate whether you agree with the majority decision or the minority concurring or dissenting opinion. Explain why.

The paper should be in APA style.

Reference:

Commonwealth of Virginia v. Allen, 609 S.E.2d 4 (Va. 2005).


Answers

Related Questions

Writing : 20180912232243political Situation In Tha...

Surname 1Students NameProfessors NameCourse TitleDatePolitical Situation in Thailand 2012Over the years, the political scene in Thailand was one marr...

History : Jubal Anderson 1...

Running header: JUBAL ANDERSON1Jubal AndersonStudent NameInstitutionCourseDateJUBAL ANDERSON2JUBA ANDERSONEarly, Juba Anderson progressed as an eight...

Psychology : The Copernican Principle 1...

Running head: THE COPERNICAN PRINCIPLEThe Copernican PrincipleStudent NameInstitutionCourseDate1THE COPERNICAN PRINCIPLE2The Copernican PrincipleNico...

Science : Double Blind 1...

Running head: DOUBLE-BLIND EXPERIMENTDouble-blind ExperimentStudent NameInstitutionCourseDate1DOUBLE-BLIND EXPERIMENT2Double-Blind ExperimentA double...

Social Science : Uk Gateway Protection Program...

Running head: UK GATEWAY PROTECTION PROGRAM1UK Gateway Protection ProgramStudent NameInstitution AffiliationUK GATEWAY PROTECTION PROGRAM2UK Gateway...

Engineering : Hydrology Final Copy...

Surname 1Your nameInstructors nameCourseDateHydrology and HydraulicsQuestion1: Maximum annual precipitation depthEmpirical Plotting Position AproachR...

If you didn't find the right answer

Ask Your Questions, We'll notify you once someone answers it